Their Strange Ways
Progressives, that is:
I’m not entirely sure what meaning they were imagined to have, or what, exactly, they were supposed to achieve, beyond status signalling by the insufferably pretentious. The kind of people to whom dishonesty is second nature.
I suppose you could think of land acknowledgements as a lesson in pretending, a schooling of the young and credulous in how to be, or seem, progressive. To master the expected pretence. The required affectations.
Readers are invited to imagine the state of mind required to be, for instance, a white journalism student and sitting through an interminable sermon about your alleged “racial guilt” and your “white supremacist colonial mindset,” your innate racial wrongness.
To put up with such shite, regularly, without booing and throwing things does seem a big ask. To inhibit such urges would, I think, take practice. So many struggle sessions.
Setting aside the non-trivial matter of tribal conquests and annexing prior to the arrival of White Devils – the massacres and scalping raids, the child abductions and slavery, the ritual torture – all presumably conducted without tearful hand-wringing – and setting aside the non-trivial issue of whether those doing the theatrical atoning intend to surrender their belongings and bugger off, the whole dynamic of land acknowledgements seems a little odd.
I mean, I’m not sure how one “mends relations,” as claimed, by endlessly reminding the descendants of violent, primitive tribes that their ancestors were dethroned by people capable of building an actual civilisation in which one might wish to live. One with wheeled vehicles, paved roads, literacy and time-keeping, sanitation and dentistry, things of that kind.
A civilisation sufficiently rich to indulge in the fatuous posturing of land acknowledgements as if they were somehow meaningful and sincere.
But such is the progressive mind.





Lefties like their humiliation rituals.
Well, I’m trying to imagine the state of mind required to be a white, middle-class journalist or journalism student and sitting through an interminable, clearly pretentious sermon about your alleged “racial guilt” and your “white supremacist colonial mindset,” your innate racial wrongness.
To put up with such shite without booing and throwing things does seem a big ask.
We made non-Indigenous Canadians, which means white founder stock Canadians, wear this hairshirt, but have they become so inured that maybe we need to upgrade to a shock collar? Half of millennials and younger think so, compared to a third of older indigenous.
And nonwhite immigrants actually like the acknowledgements because it undermines the moral confidence of founder stock whites that it’s their country and they have a right to keep people out. Once nonwhite immigrants become the majority the indigenous can’t manipulate them by guilt or pity or appeals to fair play.
[ Post updated. ]
I suppose you could think of land acknowledgements as a lesson in pretending, a schooling of the young and credulous in how to be progressive. To master the expected pretence. The required affectations.
[ Post updated again. ]
I am reading Empire of the Summer Moon, a book about the rise and fall of the Comanches.
They weren’t noble savages, they were vicious psychopaths. As were other tribes, warring with each other across North America. The closest to “civilization” were tobe found in Central and South America, where cities were established and ziggarauts built . . . only to be used to rip out the hearts of enemies in a sacrifice to the gods.
Although I dispute that we can afford this. It’s slow poison.
Appeals to fair play have a poor track record anyway in the places these immigrants are coming from.
Those so inclined can sit through the farce here.
I should add that the speaker, Allan Thompson – Mr ‘I’m white and I’m terribly sorry about it’ – is not only the head of Carleton University’s journalism programme, a supposedly “non-partisan” position, but also a failed Liberal candidate who was appointed to see how Trudeau’s Liberal Party could better connect with rural voters.
As I said in the linked piece,
So far as I’m aware, Mr Thompson is not a relation.
Also, a reminder that using the Amazon UK link in the sidebar, this one here – say, for any Christmas shopping – results in a small fee for your host at no extra cost to you.
And now back to our scheduled programming.
Sure it is.
Mr Allan Thompson, by the way, is more than happy to apologise for being white. Before being applauded for his progressive heroism.
That’s how non-partisan his department is.
One might almost think them accustomed to lying.
Which is obviously the quality you want among – checks notes – journalists.
England was invaded so many times one would need a page long “land acknowledgement” read out at every gathering…and now to be read by the new arrivals (hahaha just kidding, they get a pass, obv).
And of course some kinds of land acknowledgement are very much frowned upon.
Off topic but someone mentioned resentment at old people “hoarding” wealth. I don’t get a pension and social security is not enough. If I had not “hoarded” my wealth I would be so screwed. Just sayin. A person at retirement might live another 20 or even 30 years with no paycheck and might need big bucks for nursing care. Twits.
When my father started work after the war, he expected to live to 65. He actually lived about 25 years longer. He and Mom would have had serious financial difficulties if they had not saved religiously.
Furthermore, pensions cannot be counted on regardless of promises made.
Some context makes this even more farcical: the vast majority of Indian tribes in Ontario are not native to the area in any sense. They migrated to the area along with their British allies after the US Revolutionary War, displacing or exterminating the other tribes that were already living there.
Like so much in the current Canadian discourse around the Indian tribes, the whole thing is based on a complete fiction.
In the hierarchy of Canadian universities, Carleton is near the bottom. It’s not Brock (“If you can walk and talk, you can get into Brock”) but it’s in the same class.
It filters out the wrongthinkers.
Is ‘misislamist’ a word?
(via)
Land ACKs are of course part of the Bezmenov demoralization machine. I do wonder if this particular practice was devised by masterminds and passed down through channels or if it spontaneously arose as people (prolly AWFLs) tried to one-up each other in shows of piety.
The “cui bono” isn’t that hard to suss out: practitioners of the ACKs might reckon that it benefited the tribes to be named in public rituals, but really? What was the benefit? Were they getting their lands back? Were they being restored to their ancient place in any way? Was it lifting the reservations from poverty?
No, no it wasn’t. It was providing AWFLs and their consorts with self-flattery and higher status among other AWFLs.
As intended.
As so often, the creatures we see mouthing these things aren’t just presumptuous or mistaken or incoherent.
They’re psychologically disgusting.
Yes.
The land acknowledgements are battlespace prep for the following legal battle to extort the local governments using specious lawfare. Just like the fight for gay marriage rights was battlespace prep for using specious lawfare to silence or ruin anyone who dissented from the narrative.
I consider myself lucky because I live in Calgary. Southern Alberta actually is the recognised historic territory of a single people from whom we acquired it peacefully and honestly. We’ve always gotten along fine and there’s no reason in the world not acknowledge them. The worst you can say about the usual local acknowledgements are that they’re pointlessly pompous and technical and obsessed with treaties that the people of Alberta didn’t sign and don’t give a shit about. But there’s nothing inherently offensive about saying, “Hey, remember we bought this land from George, well, here’s his relatives!”
Most of our fellow Canadians are not so happily situated. The territory that now constitutes Manitoba and Saskatchewan was anciently inhabited by the ancestors of the Cree and the Sioux. With the onset of the Little Ice Age at the beginning of the 14th century, all that territory was abandoned, and both those peoples took the position that God had forbidden them to live there. After about a hundred years, the Cree had adapted to the new conditions in the Canadian Shield and began to expand north again there, and about fifty years later elements of the Sioux found a way to live on the prairie. The Cree had to wait until the arrival of the Hudson Bay Company and the resulting acquisition of guns before they could establish themselves on the prairie. It took them both well into the18th century to establish themselves again on the Great Plains. Both Cree and Sioux effectively excommunicated their people for living on forbidden land, and the Plains Cree and Assiniboine people who occupy those provinces today are still held at arms length by the main Cree and Sioux communities from which they sprang. So they have a clear identity and a clear claim to the country, but it’s nothing like their traditional or natural home. It’s an adventure they began at about the same time as we began ours on the same land.
In BC, there’s no shortage of traditional natives but none of them claimed the land as theirs the way the Blackfoot did here. They all regarded the land as up for grabs; you only owned it while you were actually using it, a natural enough position when there’s far more land than you need. There are natives in the Maritime and Quebec who are quite similarly situated to the people here, but as Daniel Ream has pointed out, that’s not true in Ontario. And there’s nowhere in Canada where the American style of “gosh, we were harsh to these poor buggers, weren’t we?” acknowledgement is remotely appropriate. So you could if you wanted to come up with suitable land acknowledgement in a lot of places, but belching and farting about “unceded land” as our glorious King did last year is just moronic, and yes, offensive.
Yes, but other than that, what have the Romans done for us?
Satire eventually becomes reality.
I’m gratified to see that there’s increasing pushback, but it’s still too little. I think the Natives complaining are complaining because it’s losing it’s impact. I would like to live long enough to see them go the way of the dodo.
For those south of the border who don’t have to deal with the minutiae of Canadian misgovernance, it’s worth noting that there are lots of treaties that cover the transfer of land from the Indians to the Crown, the current grifters just claim those don’t count. Or in the case of the recent B.C. legal decision, the judge simply invents a treaty that never existed.
The question of what a 21st century Western nation should do with a conquered people is simple, but unpalatable: you are One of Us now, and you may retain your traditions and culture only so far as it does not conflict with our laws and mores, and we are under no financial or legal obligation to preserve your heritage.
In the specific case of Canada’s natives there’s a much larger problem no one wants to address, because there’s no solution: between the inherent genetics, drug addiction, and rampant fetal alcohol syndrome the average Canadian native IQ is between 80 and 90. And the FAS means a lot of them have self-control and anger issues.
This came to mind.
I believe this is what’s called a short-term mindset.
I’m ready for it.
Before Europeans arrived in South Africa, there were no Negoes proper, only Bushmen because sleeping sickness kept herding peoples out of the region. Whites began to offer jobs to blacks from Nigeria and hundreds of thousands of them moved south. Now of course they are the “natives” who claim it as theirs. Ha.
“Bad luck”
‘Ware mental pronunciation – it came out as ‘Cinnabon’ in my head.
Preferably resulting in a long term.
“The undiscovered country… the future!“
And a long-term mindset should determine his punishment.
Canadian here.
The original intent, long since forgotten, was in response to a number of claims attributing various achievements to French and English settlers, which were simply not true.
Tribal elders discovered that their grandchildren were being taught in schools that Europeans had not only created some of these practices, but had taught them to the native people. That’s the exact opposite of what had happened. They complained, various textbooks were checked, the historical record supported the natives, so textbooks were corrected, and there was an acknowledgement that the natives already had those practises before the Europeans arrived.
That was it. That was all it was supposed to be.
The goal was not to shame Europeans, but for native peoples to teach their children that they had a culture before the Europeans came, one that they could be proud of. It wasn’t about racism, or guilt, it was about educating true history, not a sanitised version
Of course, it grew into a humiliation ritual, demanding that every non-native person apologise profusely for stealing the land, and all sorts of crimes that their ancestors may have committed 400 years ago.
Most of the native people I know consider it an embarrassment. They want their kids to know and be proud of their history, of course, but the entire things has been hijacked by narcissistic progressives who want everyone else to feel guilty about things they had nothing to do with.
The irony is that the progressives that want to deify the natives are even more wrong than the original textbooks that dismissed them were. Anyone who believes that native peoples were peaceful and live idyllic lives can look into the history of the Erie tribe, which Lake Eris is named after. Tribal warfare and genocides occurred long before the Europeans ever showed up.
Bill, just curious: do you have an example of one of those practices that was misattributed and later corrected? In these United States of America, for example, it seems to have always been quite the opposite, such as with the long-treasured myth about Squanto teaching the Pilgrims to bury fish together with their seeds to fertilize them, where it turns out that this was something he himself had learned during his captivity in England.
This is fun. From my favorite Canadian Ho.
The goddess of strife and discord.
Further to land acknowledgements, my municipality displays its own on the Town website. So far, so boring; you’d probably find one on most municipal websites in Ontario. It’s the Done Thing, and probably the Council thought the Done Thing was also the right thing.
But our town’s webpage goes further, insisting that “the remains of 215 children” were discovered at the Kamloops residential school, “in an unmarked mass grave”, and that “remains of hundreds of Indigenous children” had been recovered from residential school locations elsewhere.
As Daniel has pointed out on another thread, the only thing found so far at the Kamloops site were geophysical anomalies found in a ground-penetrating radar survey. Not “remains”, not “graves”, but radar bounces. And certainly not “mass graves”, a term with a very definite meaning. My letter to Council points those facts out. It also points out that I’ve done geophysical surveys and been to a real mass grave (Drobitsky Yar, east of Kharkiw).
It’s a largely new council, with a new mayor, so maybe some minds are open. Anyways, I can let any interested patrons here know whether I get a response.
Hence the disgust. It’s not just that the mouthers of these things are pretentious, inaccurate and misleading. It’s not just the cack-handedness of the affectation, its cringeworthy quality. It’s that the process they endorse and take part in, and which they inflict on others, is a deception and an insult, a kind of psychological abuse.
One in which pale-skinned students can be scolded for their “white supremacist colonial mindset,” their “racial guilt.” Hallucinatory attributes gleefully assumed.
It’s revolting.
See also this.
Same deal.
Diversity is our strength!
We don’t even know that, because they refuse to release the scans. It takes “source: trust me, kemo sabe” to a whole new level.
Well, I don’t. When I practiced Family Law in California, I could not get a wage garnishment, I could not subpoena employment records, I could not do shit when opposing party was a member of a local tribe and working at the casino on the local reservation. The tribal council would just ignore any legal proceeding and could because they were “sovereign nations.” As a result, kids went without due to deadbeat parents when it came to paying child support.
I never handled Indian adoptions but I heard that was a nightmare. Kid born and parents okay with adoption, adoptive couple eager to take the baby home, but oh, it’s 1/32 or 1/64 Indian and the tribe can come in a claim it, because that’s more federal money to them, you know.
And that casino money? Piss off the council leaders and even if you are 100% full-blooded tribal, if they kick you off the rolls . . . too bad.
See also: Great Pyramid underground megastructures, global warming data, etc.
Mis-Islamist is obviously the winner of a hijabi beauty pageant.
https://grok.com/share/bGVnYWN5LWNvcHk_36f32ff9-66c4-44af-b597-7d667994023f
From See also this, bobby b’s comment nails it.
Heh.