Piety Through Neurosis
A concerned parent, a white Slate reader, seeks counsel from the woke hive mind:
My sons have graduated, and their closest friends are still a mix of black, Hispanic, and white kids. I have never been concerned about the kids having any issues around race.
That’s nice. However, inevitably, the sky soon begins to cloud:
But one of our sons mentioned recently how irritated he is by the form he has to fill out regarding a college roommate. He has to specify his race, and all of the profiles of potential roommates he views also include race. He says all he cares about is if they are male or female and what their interests are — he doesn’t care about race.
At which point, sharp-eyed readers may sense where this is heading.
I’m doing more reading on racism, and if I’m understanding correctly, not caring about race is almost as bad as focusing only on race. Should he care what race his friends are? Is there something we should be doing or talking to our kids about before they go to college, or is it too late? Are they just as racist as someone who only has white friends, or am I worrying about nothing?
Slate’s purveyor of progressive wisdom, Michelle Herman, knows a rube when she sees one:
Not caring about or noticing race is a privilege reserved for people who are white.
A bold, indeed sweeping, claim, evidence for which is not forthcoming, presumably on grounds that time is better spent inculcating neurosis – and habitual, exploitable insecurity – all in the name of piety:
As the sociologist Megan R. Underhill, who studies race and family, has said, “White people aren’t ‘outside’ of race—they’re at the top of the racial hierarchy.” Dismissing or downplaying this reality only perpetuates inequity and violence.
Again, the precise mechanism by which these things occur, if indeed they do, is not shared with the unenlightened. We must, it seems, take such things on trust. A kind of woke gospel. However, the expectation of fretting and psychological prostration is harder to miss. You see, by not fixating tediously on every person’s melanin levels and minor variations of physiognomy – by not endlessly categorising people by their brownness, and therefore presumed suffering, and therefore innate nobility and entitlement to favours – you are, it turns out, perpetuating violence.
Please update your files and lifestyles accordingly.
Update, via the comments:
And for those morbidly curious, the end product of all this racial bean-counting and pretentious agonising – the ideal end product – can be witnessed in all its glory here. It’s quite a thing.
There are of course two possible interpretations for every Robin DiAngelo claim:
1. All white people are racist and can be divided into those who are deny their racism and those who wish to atone for it.
2. Robin DiAngelo is a racist who believes that black people are an inferior race and seeks to denigrate all white people to hobble their supposed superiority.
I suggest 2.
Prove me wrong.
For the greater good.
Holy Shit. Dr Fauci, lead immunologist on the White House Coronavirus Task Force, proudly (proudly!) announces that he deliberately lied to the American public about the efficacy of wearing masks against Coronavirus infection, to the detriment of their health and safety, for the greater good.
@Hal, thanks for the book recommendation – downloaded!
David, just for future reference, do you get a cut of any links posted, or is it necessary to go through the links above? I *think* I did it so you get paid, but I want to make sure for future reference. Thanks!!
do you get a cut of any links posted, or is it necessary to go through the links above?
Anything bought from Amazon US via this link, or from Amazon UK via the widget top right or via this link, earns me a modest commission.
In other news, I now have twelve followers on Parler. It’s terribly exciting
How…. Biblical.
Were I you I’d avoid Romans for a while.
Heh.
In other news, I now have twelve followers on Parler. It’s terribly exciting
How…. Biblical.
Were I you I’d avoid Romans for a while.
Twelve? David, yer still missing one. Mebbe you can track down Minnow to fill in.
Someone induced me to read Hayek, “The Constitution of Liberty”. Chapter six has a lengthy discussion of the difference between value and merit and why one arises from liberty and the other prevents it.
Infections do not naturally arise throughout a population all at the same time, there is always an index case. It seems to me that protests are the same. Yet, all-police-are-racists was followed closely by all-white-people-are-racists and piss-off-the-conservative-white-people-by pulling-down-the-statues all in the period of a few days. I perceive a high degree of organization yet no one is claiming to organize. Regrettably people are killed by police every year; it seems odd that we have a high degree of organized disorder this year but not last year.
The upcoming election for US president, one third of the Senate, and all of the House has nothing to do with it, of course.