Jobseeker’s Amulet
Dave Huber reports from the other side of the looking glass, where wide-eyed students are told,
A degree in Women’s and Gender Studies prepares you for almost anything.
“I do have skills,” says one graduate, rather defensively, “I do have a college degree that is meaningful.” I do, I do, I do.
Readers are invited to listen attentively for the imminent economic boom triggered by the ongoing oversupply of gender studies graduates.
HP is a deeply archetypal story filled with rich symbolism and compelling character arcs. The series’ popularity owes entirely to its depth
By comparison with children’s fantasy fiction over the last hundred years, I’d say it does not fare well at all. But I’ve learned there’s little point in analyzing works that are fan favorites; there’s an emotional investment there that provokes an extreme reaction.
Hogwarts and its ilk is, effectively, a trade school, not even a Uni
It’s a British boarding school that divides its students by class. As in social class, not what “house” they belong to. The early books are a nice little mashup of British boarding school fiction and British children’s fantasy. When Rowling tries to elevate the books to “serious” epic fantasy her inexperience as a writer shows, as does the limitations of the world she’s created.
This wouldn’t be so bad, if the snowflakes didn’t bully the colleges into requiring that real students waste time and money on these courses as well.
I liked what David Mamet said about these types:
— David Mamet, The Secret Knowledge, 2011
Objection the first: The Lord of the Rings starts as Frodo turns thirty-three, and most of the action takes place several years later.
There used to be an objection the second questioning this supposed YAFF grouping, but it and the subsequent objections have been mysteriously stricken from the record and replaced with: “Man, you must be smoking some good stuff, can I get the name of your supplier?” 😉
I think Tom is onto something with his young adult fiction theory. In my formative years I read way too many of my parents Ludlum novels, to this day I have refrained from getting a tattoo due to the fear that it would become an identifiable mark that the KGB could use to catch me.
I think Tom is onto something with his young adult fiction theory. In my formative years…
I, on the other hand suffered from early childhood Stratemeyer classics exposure, with the result that I treat friends badly and stick my nose into the business of others like the Hardy Boys and am deeply fascinated by wild and impractical swiss-army-knife technology of a Tom Swift Jr. stage.
My local library has a lot to answer for.
Lionel,
Oh dear…
[ clicks link cautiously ]
What have we here?
“There is no doubt at all that Emma’s breasts have put back the cause of women’s rights to the late 13th Century,” said Dr Keithly Liverbird head of the university’s popular Phallocentricity in Contemporary Poetry and Football Song course, “or possibly to the age of pre-Socratic Athens. Thank Christ you couldn’t actually see her nipples, or the world would’ve ended!”…
…Her colleague, Professor Clytemnestra Brassière-en-Feu, however, disagrees. She told the Mercury: ‘In revealing her breasts to the world Emma has sounded a defiant call-to-arms that will be taken up by every woman straining under the oppressive yolk of suffocating patriarchy. I only wish she’d been given the opportunity to dispense with her clothing altogether (clothes being merely another means through which men seek to assert control over women’s bodies) and was able to spread her lady garden of liberation all over the pages of that vile organ in a glorious, gynecological battle cry of liberation! But obviously the men wouldn’t let her get her muff out, would they? Oppressive, cowardly bastards!”
[ snorts loudly ]
Oh, come on now! I no longer have any doubt that the Dalston Mercury is pure satire.
(Although… as a shamelessly heterosexual male, seeing lovely Miss Watson in the altogether would not offend me.)
Micro,
Objection the first: The Lord of the Rings starts as Frodo turns thirty-three, and most of the action takes place several years later.
I think I see what they mean by it, though. As a little person, Frodo could be seen as a metaphor for the “lone teen saves the world”.
(For the record, I’ve read LOTR at least 16 times since 1972, and have devoured all the “backstory” material that Christopher Tolkien has published.)
Moving away from children’s books and back to the issue of academic absurdities and gender, What if Trump and The Failed Candidate had swapped genders asks …”Maria Guadalupe, an associate professor of economics and political science at INSEAD [some sort of alleged business school].”
To do this she “reached out” (as no one does something as mundane as “contacting”) one “…Joe Salvatore (a hipster who looks exactly as one would think he does), a Steinhardt clinical associate professor of educational theatre who specializes in ethnodrama…” at the formerly reputable NYU. I rather like that he is a “clinical” associate professor, because clinical sounds all sciencey and therefore implies some (actually absent) academic rigor.
This team of intellectual colossi had actors dress up as Miss bizzaro Trump and Mr. bizarro The Twice Failed Candidate, and then speak carefully selected lines from the debates. Upon presenting the resulting mess to a “…standing-room-only crowd, which appeared mostly drawn from academic circles…”, they were surprised to find that they liked lady bizzaro Trump more.
This allegedly proved something, something, something about gender, not just that The Twice Failed Candidate was a lousy candidate.
I guess it also demonstrated that reality and leftists are antipodal.
With a presumed average lifespan of around 120 years, and a generally juvenile approach to life being an apparent Hobbit trait, the 33 year-old Frodo IS a youngster by Hobbit standards…!
The only worthwhile tertiary course where “gender studies” is taught is where one comes out either a biologist or a medical practitioner of some kind…
Well, Jordan Peterson is a clinical psychologist…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ABa4RdNPxU
“A few weeks ago, Dr. Oren Amitay, who has been defending me in online discussions hosted by the Ontario Psychological Association, invited me to address his psychology class (to which other students were invited). We discussed freedom of speech, ideological possession, unconscious bias and the Implicit Association test, and other issues germane to psychology and the modern world.“
…you’ll be a “change agent,”…

Is that what they’re calling them now?
Why learn how to be an engineer, or God help us learn an actual trade, when you can save the world?
For his second birthday I got my nephew an early edition copy of Have Space Suit Will Travel.
I guess it also demonstrated that reality and leftists are antipodal.
Or that leftists pay more attention to the messenger than the message. Victimhood Poker dictate their entire worldview.
At the start of “Fellowship”, Frodo has just got through his “difficult tweens” and has become a barely mature adult at age 33.
Thus proving that JRRT was in possession of a time machine. How else could he have foreseen the world of 2017?
Summarizing commentary from a very old and still active mailing list:
Microbillionaire: perhaps as 33 years of age is when hobbits are considered to have ‘come of age’, thus could be considered the equivalent of our ’18’
Also, I agree with Daniel Rea, the whole ‘young person saving the world’ is not a new phenomenon. Check the bible!
Besides, who wants to read fiction about lesser struggles? ‘Young person experiences mild breakthrough with local council after months of tedium and compromise’ or ‘a young person’s journey to earn a free loyalty card coffee only to give said away coffee to a deserving transient’. I’ll keep my HP thanks 🙂
The “studies” people oftentimes wind up in my department (English — or what used to be English, before the “studies” got ahold of it…I’m old enough to remember lecture courses given by older profs who were not convinced of critical theory and questioned Saussure and Derrida; that would appear quaint and archaic by today’s standards).
They can’t read critically; they can’t write; they can’t think — about all they are good at is studiously demanding that students memorize (not learn, memorize the form) how to cite articles using MLA with extreme precision *which is a waste of time as the bloody things change every so often and not every department demands the same style* and bullying and butt kissing, which garners them advancements.
And so goes the humanities.
PS. If you read LoTR, Frodo isn’t exactly the only heroic character (Tolkien weaved many different forms of heroism throughout his book and none of them are without flaw), nor is he 100% heroic (he comes off as a feeble prat quite often)…and it is the character of Sam, his trusty and unpretentious batsman, who really gets ‘er done (perhaps a hold over of JRR’s war time experiences). I find his works quite enjoyable on that level…certainly a vast improvement over Rowling (ok for the 8 yo. set to cut their teeth on, but truly derivative and ultimately boring) — although I can see why the “studies” folks love her: when you can’t really read for comprehension because your education is so lacking in context and even basic grammar function, then you aren’t going to like anything weightier than HP (or any science beyond Bill Nye).
When people with such degrees do find professional careers (as opposed to >entry-level positions in the food services industry), what kind of career is most common?
They hold protests and otherwise raise a stink about perceived race/sex/albeism and demand the offending entity hire such graduates as “diversity officers” and such, once inside a company they grow like cancer until it dies, like twitter is in the process of doing. Haven’t heard of any of them starting careers suing for being mis-gendered in New York City, but I’m just waiting for it.
No fries with KFC in USA? Well I be buggered!
IMO KFC is the greatest fast food on the planet. It can be eaten hot or cold, whereas most fast food is disgusting if not eaten immediately. It comes with greenery in the coleslaw, because I need some greenery with every meal or I feel unwell. And you can dunk the fries in the gravy for a double carbohydrate buzz to counteract the protein and fat of the chicken.
But now I find that in the place of its birth it is substandard. That’s such a buzzkill.
(before anyone argues pizza is a greater fast food, that is a category error. Pizza is merely food, as evidenced by it being served at quite flash places.)
Okay, if you seriously want to take this tack, let me note two of my further objections:
-Frodo isn’t lone. From the other hobbits to the Fellowship to Gollum, his quest is always in company. The only time he can reasonably be said to be even briefly alone is when he’s captured by orcs (and Sam has to save him). Even his last small-group segment in Mordor is enabled by people like Aragorn drawing away the eye and armies of Sauron.
-Frodo doesn’t save the world. He betrays the world at the last moment and takes the Ring for his own. Providence saves the world as evil ruins things for evil in the end. (Presumably the book is old enough now that this doesn’t need a spoiler warning.)
‘Young person experiences mild breakthrough with local council after months of tedium and compromise’ or ‘a young person’s journey to earn a free loyalty card coffee only to give said away coffee to a deserving transient’.
Transported to a surreal landscape, a young girl kills the first person she meets and then teams up with three strangers to kill again.
Tom Cruise is a soulless recluse who lurks in the darkness and sucks the life from all who come near him. He’s also in this movie about a vampire.
An eccentric nanny hired by a wealthy family subjects the children to a series of psychedelic experiences and cult-like character building exercises.
A federal agent in Chicago hampers the work of an enterprising American job creator.
Etc.
. . . and the Hobbit commentary is reminding me of a so far otherwsie unused commercial bit I thought up sometime back regarding Knees And Toes, the anti dandruff shampoo for hobbits . . .
Oh, and aside from putting in a fix for a broken tag, definitely stick to the Tolkien LOTR and Hobbit . . .
Of something claiming to be related to the latter, I did see Jackson’s An Unfortunate Train Wreck to see what 48fps looks like—looked fine—and then just didn’t bother with The Desolation Of Smog or The Desecration Of Smaug and finally The Battle Of The Five Accountants.
The best commentary I ran across on Jackson’s version of the other is definitely by Cleolinda Jones, but no idea where that’s disappeared to online…
I did see Jackson’s An Unfortunate Train Wreck…and then just didn’t bother with The Desolation Of Smog or The Desecration Of Smaug and finally The Battle Of The Five Accountants.
Never saw the original trilogy. Instead I found an edited version online which scrubbed all the Jacksonian twaddle and pared the three movies down to one, which was fairly loyal to the original story. Quite enjoyable if you can track it down. Something like “There and Back Again, a Hobbit’s Tale Recut”. That’s what it’s labelled as in my Videos folder anyway. Runs just over three hours.
@Chester: I have had KFC in South Korea, some sixteen years ago. Excellent at the time, and faithful to the original recipe except for a preference for increased red pepper. So much so, that the white meat was dramatically stained under the breading.
SK has some interesting pizza options such as squid as well, of course. And yet, as of about six years ago, the art of the ordinary burger was sorely lacking, even at US brand outlets. Don’t even get me started on Lotte Burger…
before anyone argues pizza is a greater fast food
Until I can drive up to the window for take-away, it ain’t fast food.
Prolly not so loose paraphrase: I have a business, and by definition, that business is required to be successful. . . Rather reminiscent of Ok, I showed up, where’s my trophy?!?!?!!
DC restaurant alleges unfair competition in suit against Trump, DC hotel, and related headlines . . .
Ok. So given that Trump had the hotel before the election, and given that Trump then ran for POTUS, rather than the position of DC hotel owner, perhaps y’all instead should sue those customers and prospective customers of the hotel, and perhaps also sue everyone who voted for Trump . . .
And in other news of capitalism, entrepreneurship, and self reliance in action: Woman gets prison for taking over husband’s meth sales