It Just Happened
In the comments, Mr Muldoon steers us to this girthy lady and her list of complaints:
Smaller plus-size people, please check your privilege. That includes a mid-fat like me who is FAR more privileged than folks larger than me. I’m honestly so sick of people including small fats and thinking that’s enough… and I’m sick of small fats not calling out the fact that they are the biggest people at the event/shoot/meeting or whatever it is. Fat people above a 20 exist, and we fucking matter. We deserve to be included and seen. Super fat people deserve to be included. Infini-fat people deserve to be included. Fat people of colour deserve to be included. Disabled fat people deserve to be included. We all matter too. Your body positivity isn’t shit if it doesn’t include us.
Setting aside the intersectional hierarchy of fatness – small-fat, mid-fat, super-fat and infini-fat – there is, I think, something odd about the chosen language. In woke usage, the word privilege implies arbitrariness, some random quirk of life, an attribute or circumstance unrelated to one’s own efforts or choices. As if becoming sufficiently vast to engage in fat activism, and bang on about privilege, were merely a matter of the planets aligning a certain way. As if anyone might become colossally fat spontaneously, overnight, with no warning, and through no action, or inaction, of their own. Which doesn’t sound terribly plausible. In fact, it sounds like an attempt to displace responsibility and thereby deceive.
Also, open thread.
have been surprised by your reasoning
I suspect you’d be surprised by reasoning, period, since your posts remain remarkably free from its insidious tendrils.
I mean, you’re not quite into so-what-you’re-saying-is-I’m-a-lobster territory, but damn near.
I have no idea what that is. Did it involve piling small rocks on top of larger rocks and then skipping around them?
Posted by: David | May 29, 2019 at 21:32
…
So did you have Big Wheels?
Being good-hearted children, we played traditional British fun-time activities. Like Whose Shoes Are These?, Rattle The Box, and Jigger-Ma-Hoop.
Dad? Is that you?
Presumably, you’ve all heard the idiom, “a sight for sore eyes.”
Well I mistakenly clicked on the embedded link, and that’s “a sight that makes my eyes sore.”
Heh.
I suspect you’d be surprised by reasoning, period, since your posts remain remarkably free from its insidious tendrils
Miaou!
I confess that I generally give people’s weight little thought, up to the moment they can no longer walk along with me, at which point I tend to lose interest in their company.
In case there was any doubt.
“Ooh, it’s all kicking off”.
Or, “Former Communist Paul Mason demonstrates again that he doesn’t really like the proletariat”, plus some general Leftie in-fighting.
Jigger-Ma-Hoop.
Actually Googled that to check.
Gentle readers, in our never ending search for knowledge the question of “just what the hell is ‘super-fat’, ‘infini-fat'” and so on, my crack team of researchers here at the Muldoon Institute and Plantations have found the answer to “rethinking the farthest end of the fat spectrum”.
You’re welcome.
The above was brought to you by the curvy¹ ladies² at The Far Lip, “A fat libration podcast”.
¹(In much the same way a barrage balloon is curvy) ²(YMMV, I am uncharacteristically trying to be polite)
But what should we fats on the very very very fat end of the fat spectrum be called?
Fatty, fatty boombalatty?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zr8mO59gmiE
“Fat spectrum”
How about subfatties, fatties, and superfatties, to borrow terminology from the
Hertzsprung-Russell diagram? And the loonies would be “off the main sequence”?
The funny thing is that it never occurred to me to make fun of fat people until the “woke” fat “activists” started behaving so obnoxiously.
Super fat … Infini-fat … Fat people of colour
What about the suffering of the chronically under-fat? What about their lived experience?
“Fat spectrum”?
Exactly. What is with this spectrum nonsense? This isn’t a band or range or qualifier of something like light but a quantifier of size, of mass. If Fatty Boombalatty (as stated previously, my preference) how about:
deca-fatty
hecto-fatty
kilo-fatty
mega-fatty
giga-fatty
tera-fatty
peta-fatty
exa-fatty
zetta-fatty
yotta-fatty
And THEN fatty-boombalatty, fatty-fatty-boombalatty, and on from there? Just trying to help.
What about the suffering of the chronically under-fat? What about their lived experience?
Indeed, and what of the anorexics, all of whom identify as fat ?
…it never occurred to me to make fun of fat people until the “woke” fat “activists” started behaving so obnoxiously.
TBF, it occurred to me, but I generally restrained myself, but now, for the same reason, generally feel no such compulsion. The authoress and host of The Fat Lip (do not click, you have been warned) of the the “spectrum” above is not “oppressed”, “marginalized”, “erased”, “an object of discrimination”, (or any other SJW claptrap term) because no one makes size ∞X clothes, extra wide airplane seats, or any other reason the world is not made to conform to people so far to the right of the mean their SD is in a different time zone.
OTOH, maybe I should hop on the sweet, sweet oppression train because it is almost impossible for me to walk into a shoe store and find anything larger than a 12 1/2 D, the damn foot shaming podiphobes.
“What about the suffering of the chronically under-fat? What about their lived experience?”
White dwarfs, red dwarfs, brown dwarfs….
One ‘fucking’ and one ‘shit’. Things are looking up, for it is usually every two to three paragraphs that a clutch of pointless expletives are used to buttress the epistolary blustering of such adolescent Weltanschauung.
OTOH, maybe I should hop on the sweet, sweet oppression train because it is almost impossible for me to walk into a shoe store and find anything larger than a 12 1/2 D, the damn foot shaming podiphobes.
Heh. I was thinking the same thing. And WTF is it with a shoe-size 13 foot requiring a size 14 sock? Thanks to my trying-too-hard mother-in-law who has heard (mostly from my wife) that I have a hard time finding socks that fit, I have drawers full of size 13 socks. Most of which need to be stretched to fit…then I met a man who had no shoes…
…I have a hard time finding socks that fit…
WTP – Thorlos, full and half sizes up to 17 1/2. A little pricey, but worth it, last forever. If you want Justin
CastreauxTrudeau fashion socks, you’ll be SOL, but everyday wear, no problem.Of possible relevance to the discussion of the gravitationally advantaged: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=judge+dredd+fatties&t=palemoon&iax=images&ia=images.
Farnsworth…Thanks for that. Though they make socks explicitly for Pickleball? Hmmm…
Though they make socks explicitly for Pickleball?
Well, yeah, they have fully embraced and celebrate all aspects of footist culture, podiphobes are not welcomed or tolerated at Thorlos.
Plus, if you are a pickleball player, there could be some of that fine endorsement money in it for you.
Plus, if you are a pickleball player,
Well, speaking as a swimmer I feel exceptionally discriminated against by the socks-making industrial complex. As far as I know, they have totally ignored us.
As far as I know, they have totally ignored us.
Once again, the Muldoon Institute and Plantations researchers are here to serve your knowledge needs.
I see your aluminum tent poles, and raise.
I have been wondering, for years, where that phrase came from and now I know. Thank you.
I suspect you’d be surprised by reasoning, period, since your posts remain remarkably free from its insidious tendrils.
So you’re saying Canadians aren’t nice?
Heeled shoes cause schizophrenia.
What, you didn’t know?
Heeled shoes cause schizophrenia.
Perhaps this is obvious…or not, I’m never sure about the things that I see…Might seeing a connection between heeled shoes and schizophrenia itself be a sign of mild schizophrenia? Or is seeing a connection between the seeing of a connection between heeled shoes and schizophrenia being a sign of schizophrenia possibly a sign of mild (or possibly severe?) schizophrenia?
And yes, can you tell I’m bored today?
And yes, can you tell I’m bored today?
The ruminations about the difficulties of finding adequately commodious socks was steering me to that conclusion.
[ Slides box of dominoes along bar. ]
small-fat, mid-fat, super-fat and infini-fat
A modest suggestion. Instead of numerous, multiplying categories, why don’t we use body fat percentage, similar to how we rate ground beef? This will allow a continuum of privilege ratings, surely the ultimate in wokefullness. Perhaps we can append our privilege to our names: Killer Marmot 21.614% and so on. In truth, that is actually reverse privilege, as a small value means greater privilege,
Similarly we can measure people’s skin tone on a continuous scale, and add that to each rating. Of course, we’ll have to measure it from somewhere not exposed to the sun, so as not to benefit the tanners among us.
Similarly we can measure people’s skin tone on a continuous scale, and add that to each rating.

I’ll leave this here while I fetch something from the cellar.
Empowered positivity, and you just know that grant money is involved:
The original Butterdance
So you’re saying Canadians aren’t nice?
You can’t be nice and win the Cooper’s Hill Cheese Rolling and Wake.
The ruminations about the difficulties of finding adequately commodious socks was steering me to that conclusion.
Great, another foot shaming podophobe weighing in with you normopods constantly exerting your pedal superiority by erasing the lived experience of the oppression and marginalization of we people of hyperpedalism being denied our right to plantar comfort.
Right. What Farnsworth said.
My son wears a 14 or a 15, depending on which orthotics he has on.
We’re gonna need a bigger tent.
@Pogonip
Preach, sister, these normopods have no idea of the shaming hell we go through, “nice gunboats”, “Hey Bigoot”, “clown shoes”, “yow, check the clodhoppers”, “those feet are longer than a week of Mondays”, “he could walk a mile in three steps”, the horror, the horror…
Hey, you know what they say about big feet…
Hey, you know what they say about big feet…
It’s twoo, it’s twoo…
“It’s twoo, it’s twoo…”
I would like to thank our new sheriff for all he has done.
So would I.
I always wonder why if life in America is so horrible why do you stay?. This couldn’t possible be about separating the gullible from their money, could it?
Darleen: not just money. I know leftists who have made it very clear that they resent the fact that there are people who do not live as they think we all should.
Farnsworth, our society is unbearably prejudiced against feet of size.
they resent the fact that there are people who do not live as they think we all should.
IOW, they are all Ivy Starnes – and there’s no placating that evil. Soul vampires.
I always wonder why if life in America is so horrible why do you stay?
There’s always Liberia.
There’s always Liberia.
True, but other than an occasional gullible UN type, no one to cage a free meal from while you get harangued about how much you suck.
The Butterdancer looks unnervingly like my aunt would if my aunt gained 70 pounds and didn’t know to keep her feet out of the butter.
That wasn’t the original Butter Dance, you know. Adele? You really think such a work of art mates with something so pedestrian? Philistines. From the NYT article regarding this artist:
Word. I encourage, no I implore you to RTWT:
https://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/13/arts/international/indonesias-maverick-performance-artist.html
When I worked as a medic I ran out of a volunteer station which had the only bariatric ambulance and stretcher(everything extra-wide and heavy-duty) in town so it saw a lot of service. We normally staffed a call with two-person teams (driver and medic) and if a lift was more than two could handle we had Dispatch send firefighters for Lifting Assistance. In-house, and informally, we tended to categorize bariatric calls by the number of firefighters necessary to safely perform the lift/move from the patient’s actual location to stretcher to ambulance. Firefighters themselves had an additional criterion, based on whether they judged it necessary to deploy The Man-Sack to accomplish the transfer. The most I can recall at one time was 6, plus the driver and me, Man-Sack deployed; the memory still makes my hands sweat.
we tended to categorize bariatric calls by the number of firefighters necessary to safely perform the lift
It may be a life-shortening condition that jeopardises your health in a dozen different ways, and which can also endanger the people trying to save your life, as illustrated above; but I’ve been told we’re supposed to call it body positivity.