Elsewhere (69)
Via Simen, Daniel Greenfield talks us through the Victim Value Index:
Historical suffering transmuted into guilt is the gold standard of liberalism, but suffering is relative. In our wonderful multi-everything society, there are so many groups with so many claims to pain. Everyone agrees that the Heteronormative Caucasian Patriarchy of Doom is to blame for all of it, but that still leaves the question of dividing up the spoils of the system and all the privileges to be gained from denouncing privilege. A caste system doesn’t work without priority, and calculating the priority of privilege claims by the perpetually underprivileged is complicated. Without the Victim Value Index, understanding how these priorities work can be confusing, even for liberals. It’s particularly confusing for conservatives and libertarians who don’t understand the system and dismiss it as liberal insanity. It is insane, the way all cultural taboos are, but there is a method to the madness.
A. Barton Hinkle on Obama, pencils and who deserves what:
A complex society is necessary for the creation of business, but it is not sufficient. Countless people made modern computing and the internet possible. But Elon Musk, not anybody else, made PayPal happen. And even if that were not so – even if Musk’s contribution to the creation of PayPal were no greater than the contribution from Phil, the goateed baristo at Starbucks with the Occupy Everything sticker on his car – Obama’s approach leaves a crucial question unanswered: Why should Phil, rather than Elon, enjoy the proceeds from PayPal’s success? Suppose you sell me a pencil. You didn’t make that. Still, I freely gave my dollar to you. How much right do you have to that dollar? That’s hard to say, but this is not: You have far more right to keep it than any third party has to take it away.
And Glenn Reynolds on two ways to pitch a campaign and Obama’s track record:
The Obama administration sold its near trillion dollar “stimulus” plan by claiming that without it, unemployment would reach 9% while with it, unemployment would stay below 8%. Despite the bill, unemployment hit 10% and has, in fact, remained more than 8% for the past 42 months. The “stimulus” money, meanwhile, seems to have vanished into a welter of crony-capitalism deals of which the Solyndra debacle is only the most famous. And all that “hope and change” from the administration has turned to “attack and blame” as Obama and his surrogates launch one assault after another in an effort to turn the conversation to anything besides the economy. So much for the promised Bright New Day. With trillion dollar deficits as far as the eye can see, and the exploding national debt (which Obama called unconscionable when it was about half as big as it has become under his stewardship), it seems time for a Back To Basics approach. And that’s clearly the direction favoured by Romney, the turnaround artist who specialised in taking mismanaged entities and making them work. His choice of Ryan simply takes it to a new level. As Internet humourist IowaHawk tweeted on Saturday: “Paul Ryan represents Obama’s most horrifying nightmare: Math.”
Yes, it’s often fun to watch bluster collide with maths.
Feel free to add your own links and snippets in the comments.
A caste system doesn’t work without priority,
Nutshell.
And as Daniel Greenfield explains in his article, when two Designated Victim Groups collide – say, if brown-skinned thugs assault a white-skinned gay man – calculating the relative victim values can get quite tricky. It’s like suddenly having to do long division in your head while jumping up and down. I’ve actually seen this kind of calculation first-hand, in real time. You could practically hear the grinding of mental gears as the person concerned tried to figure out which party they should pretend to care about.
See also this:
And of course this.
I think this site is great, and I read Daniel Greenfield avidly too. Thank goodness that are two voices of sanity in the world, at least.
David,
I’m somewhat disappointed – or perhaps amazed?
How could the source of some of the best snark on the internet miss linking this issue to “Victimhood Poker”?
http://dicklist.blogspot.com.au/2006/07/tdl-gaming-world-series-of-victimhood.html
Here’s a fun one:
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2012/08/13/leftist_planet?page=full
Thomas Sowell is (as usual) worth a squint:
Shocking news…
“A Freedom of Information response obtained by The Commentator website has revealed that the BBC buys more copies of the Guardian than any other national newspaper. Nearly 60,000 copies of Rusbridger’s rag could be found in Beeb buildings between April 2010 and February 2011, over 10,000 more than the Daily Mail. That’s despite the Mail having a circulation approaching ten times that of the Guardian.”
http://order-order.com/2012/08/14/bbc-buys-the-guardian-more-than-any-other-paper/
So glad my license fee is bailing out the Guardian.
“the BBC buys more copies of the Guardian than any other national newspaper”
Who’d have thunk?
Nice review from Charles Moore recently of a book by a former Islamic militant, Maajid Nawaz. Born and bred in Britain, he joined Hizb al-Tahrir (HT), an organisation that talks of establishing a new Muslim Caliphate. Whilst in prison in Egypt, he changed his views.
“Despite his rhetorical devotion to Islam, he had been obsessively political, and knew little about the religion in whose name he had struggled and plotted. In jail, he studied. He also met lots of other people, including secularists, imprisoned for beliefs quite unlike his own. He found that he respected them”
He talks of how his extremism was tolerated in Britain:
“The liberal Left were particularly credulous: ‘How we Islamists laughed at their naivety’…In college, HT could easily turn the Islamic Society into its front organisation, and students had no trouble carrying knives at all times. ‘Hate speech’ which, Nawaz writes, would have been jumped on if it had come from the BNP, was indulged because it came from people with brown skin. In Pakistan, teaching English via the British Council was a recognised means of livelihood for HT agitators. Our host culture was so abject that it effectively incited attacks upon itself”
Well worth further investigation.
The “stimulus” money, meanwhile, seems to have vanished into a welter of crony-capitalism deals of which the Solyndra debacle is only the most famous.
But on the upside, Obama did say he’d make energy prices ‘skyrocket’.
So there’s that.
Henry,
“The liberal Left were particularly credulous: ‘How we Islamists laughed at their naivety’…”
I recall the Guardian’s Natasha Walter confidently describing Hizb ut-Tahrir as “an alternative to capitalism” and champions of women’s rights. At the time of her blathering, the group’s official on-line constitution explained how those “women’s rights” would involve compulsory segregation of the sexes, limited voting and enforced “modesty.” But Ms Walter was much too busy swooning over Angry Brown People to actually read what these obnoxious little fascists wish to bring about.
A few weeks later, Madeleine Bunting conducted her ludicrous Hello-style interview with Yusuf al-Qaradawi, during which she enthused about his “horror of immorality and materialism,” his “independence of mind” and his mastery of the internet. Bunting was of course careful to skip over the content of Qaradawi’s website, which, at the time of her interview, celebrated suicide bombing, the murdering of gay people and the beating of disobedient women. For Allah, naturally.
The above, incidentally, are two of the reasons – the many, many reasons – why this T-shirt exists.
I.6 billion of OPM gone (“It’s GONE, MacReady!”) in the MF Global rip-off, and Jon Corzine isn’t even being looked at by the SEC.
(sound of crickets)
What’s ironic about “you didn’t build that” is that it ought to be directly contradictory to all those people who think Obama is a Marxist. After all, isn’t he saying that the Labor Theory of Value is bunk?
The “stimulus” money, meanwhile, seems to have vanished into a welter of crony-capitalism deals of which the Solyndra debacle is only the most famous.
Green energy firm sacks two-thirds of American workforce days after receiving $32 million government loan.